Skip to content
comparison

Grate Magnet vs Drawer Magnet for Food and Feed Lines

Both use the same magnetic tubes, but they differ in housing, cleaning and how much iron they catch. Here is how to choose between them for flour, sugar, spices and feed.

Latif Engineering4 min read

If you run a food, flour or feed plant, the two magnets you will meet most often are the grate magnet and the drawer magnet. Both are built from the same thing: rows of stainless steel tubes with strong magnets inside. The difference is everything around those tubes.

What each one is

Grate magnet

A grate magnet is a simple frame of tubes that drops into a hopper, bin inlet or chute opening. It has no housing of its own. You lift it out to clean it.

Drawer magnet

A drawer magnet is a closed housing with flanges at the top and bottom, fitted in-line on a chute. Inside are two or three rows of tubes, each row on its own drawer that slides out for cleaning.

How they compare

Installation

A grate sits in an existing opening and needs almost no change to the plant. A drawer magnet is bolted into a chute, so the chute has to be cut or a flange added.

Dust

A grate is open to the air on top, so it is best where dust is not a problem or where it sits inside a closed hopper. A drawer magnet is sealed, which matters for fine powders like flour, milk powder and spices.

Number of rows

Grates are usually one or two rows. Drawer magnets typically have two or three staggered rows, so every particle passes close to a tube more than once. More rows means better capture of fine iron.

Cleaning

To clean a grate, someone lifts it out and wipes it, and product may flow past without protection while they do. With a drawer magnet, one drawer is cleaned at a time while the others keep working. Easy-clean drawers, with tubes inside sleeves, let iron drop into a tray without anyone touching the tubes.

Cost

A grate costs less. A drawer magnet costs more because of the housing, seals and drawers.

Which one for which product?

  • Whole grain, maize, pulses, plastic granules: a grate is usually enough.
  • Flour, semolina, starch: a drawer magnet, for dust control and more rows.
  • Sugar and salt: a drawer magnet. For brown sugar or moist sugar that sticks, a rotating grate magnet keeps it flowing.
  • Spices and chilli powder: a sealed drawer magnet with easy-clean drawers, because cleaning is frequent and the dust is unpleasant.
  • Poultry and cattle feed: a grate at intake, a drawer magnet before the pellet mill.

What really decides performance

The housing matters, but the tubes matter more. Three things make the difference:

  1. Magnet grade. Neodymium pulls far harder than ferrite at the tube surface and is needed for fine iron.
  2. Tube spacing. Narrow gaps catch more but can block with poor-flowing products.
  3. Pole spacing inside the tube. More poles per metre means more collection points along each tube.

A cheap grate with neodymium tubes can outperform an expensive drawer magnet with weak ferrite tubes. When comparing quotes, ask what is inside the tubes. If you only need replacement tubes for an existing frame, magnetic rods can be made to the same size.

Where a hopper magnet fits in

On plastic moulding and extrusion machines there is a third option: a hopper magnet, which is a small drawer-type housing made to bolt between the hopper and the machine throat.

Summary

  • Grate: lower cost, easy to fit, best for coarse free-flowing material.
  • Drawer: sealed, more rows, quicker cleaning, best for fine powders and food.
  • Both: only as good as the tubes inside and how often they are cleaned.

Tell us your product, chute size and flow rate, and we will suggest the right one. Request a quote.

Frequently asked questions

Is a drawer magnet stronger than a grate magnet?

Not by itself. Strength comes from the magnet grade in the tubes. A drawer magnet usually has more rows, which improves capture.

Which is better for flour?

A drawer magnet, because it is sealed against dust and has more rows for fine iron.

What if my product sticks to the tubes?

Use wider tube spacing or a rotating grate magnet, which turns its tubes to keep product moving.

WhatsApp us