Skip to content
comparison

Overband Magnet vs Magnetic Pulley: Which One Suits Your Conveyor?

Both remove tramp iron from a conveyor, but they work from opposite sides of the belt. Here is how they compare on burden depth, cost, space and maintenance, and when to use both.

Latif Engineering3 min read

If you need to take tramp iron off a conveyor, the two most common answers are an overband magnet and a magnetic pulley. Both clean themselves, and both protect whatever comes after the conveyor. But they work from opposite sides of the belt, and that one difference decides which one suits your plant.

How each one works

Overband magnet

An overband hangs above the belt. It has a strong magnet with its own short belt running around it. Iron is lifted up out of the material, carried sideways by the small belt and thrown clear into a bin. Read more on the overband electro magnet separator and the overband permanent magnet separator.

Magnetic pulley

A magnetic pulley replaces the conveyor head pulley. It pulls iron down against the belt. As the material leaves the belt, the iron stays on a little longer and drops behind a splitter into a separate chute.

The comparison, point by point

Burden depth

This is the most important difference. A pulley works from the bottom, so iron lying on top of a deep layer of material is furthest from the magnet and can escape. An overband works from the top and is mounted close to the surface of the burden.

  • Shallow burden: a pulley works well.
  • Deep burden: an overband is usually the better choice.

Size of tramp iron

Overbands handle large, heavy pieces well, especially electro models with a deep field. Pulleys are better at small pieces lying near the belt, like nuts, washers and wire.

Space

A pulley takes no extra space at all, because it sits where the head pulley already is. An overband needs a support structure above the belt and room to the side for the discharge.

Cost

A magnetic pulley is generally the lower cost option, because it is one component with no extra structure. An overband costs more but covers more situations.

Power

A permanent pulley needs no power. An overband needs power for its belt drive, and an electro overband also needs power for the coil. A permanent overband avoids the coil.

Maintenance

A pulley has very little to look after. An overband has a belt, bearings and a drive that need routine checks, like any small conveyor.

When to choose which

Choose a magnetic pulley when:

  • Burden is shallow and evenly spread.
  • Space above the belt is limited.
  • You are designing a new conveyor and can build separation in.
  • Tramp iron is mostly small pieces.

Choose an overband when:

  • Burden is deep, such as on crusher feed or cane carriers.
  • Tramp iron is large and heavy.
  • You need to protect a crusher, mill or shredder.
  • You want separation along the belt, not only at the head.

Using both together

On lines that protect expensive machines, plants often fit both. The overband takes out large iron from the top of the burden, and the pulley catches what was hidden underneath. Together they cover the whole depth of the material. If you need cleaner separation than a pulley gives, a separate drum magnetic separator at the transfer point is another option.

Quick decision guide

  1. Is the burden deeper than about 150 mm? Lean towards an overband.
  2. Is there no room above the belt? Use a pulley.
  3. Is the iron large and the machine downstream expensive? Overband, or both.
  4. Is budget tight and the burden shallow? A pulley is a sensible start.

Every conveyor is different. Send us the belt width, speed, burden depth and the kind of iron you find, and we will recommend the right one. Request a quote.

Frequently asked questions

Is a magnetic pulley cheaper than an overband?

Generally yes, because it replaces an existing pulley and needs no support structure.

Can a magnetic pulley handle deep burden?

It works from below, so iron on top of a deep burden can escape. For deep burden, an overband is usually better.

Can I use both on one conveyor?

Yes. The overband removes iron from the top and the pulley catches what is underneath.

WhatsApp us